Research paper: Supreme Court Case

6 min read
17 October 2023

The Supreme Court has been the agent of change on matters about the government, constitution, and American Culture, which is notable in major cases of ruling that have been witnessed in the past. In this case, one of the most prominent cases that lead to a different course of how the law is applied and implemented is the court ruling of "Plessy Ferguson (1896),” the case involved racial segregation and its connection to the constitution. Based on this ruling the Supreme Court decided that there is indeed racial segregation, and that does not mean it violates the constitution, but that each race should be placed on equal order and quality. The approach of accepting differences in how race exists is important as long as it applies equally in this aspect. The doctrine of "separate but equal" was developed which was to guide the reconstruction of black American rights and politics in how things are done by having a representative in every aspect to bring equality in racial matters (Bartz and Kritsonis 4). In light of the line of the case, the Supreme Court has shaped or been shaped by the law amendment because the court's functions of making a ruling a crucial role in creating a way and turning point for the country. Therefore, the case of "Plessy Ferguson (1896)," has paved the way for many things about racial segregation because solutions to the rooted issue of racial segregation and discrimination were something that needed court rulings that would change everything for the better. The parties involved in the case that happened and upheld in 1896 included Homer Plessy and the railroad in the challenge of the "Separate Car Act,” because it was viewed that it did not perceive African-Americans as inferior but it was due to the issue of state to make reforms on the policy (Contact term paper writers using this link).


       Moreover, the Supreme Court ruling in the case of "Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)," was to decide on the issue of contention which included the "Separate Car Act,"  where racial segregation and violations of law were issues. The plaintiff  Homer Plessy brought the case through his Attorney and advocated changing the law that violated the amendment of policies. However, the railroad being the defendant used advocates to find refuge by claiming that allowing it to buy more cars for the different races was to make it incur more expense than it had planned (Bartz and Kritsonis 5).  In this case, these were the major issues that were in the contention that led to challenges of this issue that revolved around policy and legal amendment of laws that would streamline the railroad operations with segregation or discrimination of colour and racial differences. Also, the cultural situation in 1896 was about racial segregation, oppression, and discrimination, especially for the Americans, because they did not have equal rights to access different facilities as the whites. The culture where the blacks and whites segregate each other brought a revolutionary change in how things are done in the railroad and other places where there is racial separation and equality  (Hire Dissertation writer  experts).

 
The case is of utmost importance because it was raised at this time of the 1896 era because African-Americans were not allowed to access equal opportunities as whites when it came to boarding the railroad. In this era, the cultural implication of how races treated each other needed important amendments to change that societal notion that led to the suppression of blacks as inferior and had not equal rights as their counterparts white people facilities. The case of Homer Plessy is a typical example that guided the Supreme Court in making new laws and amendments about the constitutional approach to racial segregation and violations of laws made (Palermo and Fusani 399). Therefore, the Supreme Court ruled that it was important to acknowledge there should be equality for different races without one looking at another as inferior. Still, it argued that the Constitution did not violate the existing laws about racial segregation. Still, more amendment to the policy was important to change the negative impacts of racial segregation and discrimination (Bartz and Kritsonis 6). In this case, the doctrine of separate but equal was born to drive the Supreme Court decision and ruling about the case. It was to be implemented across Louisiana, and anyone who did not adhere to it was charged or imprisoned.


Additionally, the Supreme Court decision on the case of "Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)," had a great effect and impact on the era when there was the reconstruction of politics in the inclination of the Black American race to fight for their rights. The notable effect of the Supreme Court ruling is several amendments of laws such as the 1875 Civil Rights Act that considered it a crime for a person to fail to adhere to new legal reforms on racial equality about things and accommodations. I chose the case of "Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)," because it forms an important basis and influence on how the reconstruction of Black American politics and rights was achieved in the era where there was racial segregation and discrimination. The case is influential because it changed the course of history as pertains to racial segregation and the inferiority of certain races over others (Palermo and Fusani 400). Therefore, the case is influential because it made the supreme court rule over the existing laws, by deciding that reforms and amendments need to be made to ensure that it accommodates the racial needs and rights of all people regardless of their colour.

 

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the author by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.
Rubina Rubi 2
Joined: 5 months ago
Comments (0)

    No comments yet

You must be logged in to comment.

Sign In / Sign Up