Should You Go with a PEO or a Payroll Provider?

Should You Go with a PEO or a Payroll Provider?
6 min read
14 December 2023

While employees are necessary for running a business, PEO service providers may make hiring, managing, and retaining them much more accessible.

Most business owners are experts in their field, but no one can be an expert in everything – and successfully managing complex HR systems typically necessitates significant effort and specialized knowledge.

Working with a professional employer organization (PEO) is like having your own highly qualified human resources department devoted to assisting you with people-related issues so you can focus on operating the business. Many business owners working with these groups must know the breadth of services available. PEO service providers can collaborate with you to deliver much more than simply payroll and recruiting.

What exactly is a PEO?

A professional employer organization (PEO) is a third-party service provider that enters into a co-employment relationship with an employer to provide critical HR services such as payroll, employee benefits administration, risk management, and compliance help. Using a PEO allows businesses to outsource HR responsibilities they need more time, budget, or competence to do in-house.

What is the definition of a payroll service provider?

A payroll service provider is a business that assists employers with payroll and tax-related activities. They often do not handle further HR duties or administrative tasks outside of payroll, but they can frequently recommend additional suppliers for benefits, insurance, and other services.

In payroll, what does PEO stand for?

Payroll services address all aspects of employee payroll within the firm. A PEO can handle the following services for a client company:

  • Employee wage and compensation payments are calculated and processed.
  • Employee income tax, payroll taxes, unemployment taxes, and other applicable taxes are withheld.
  • Making appropriate deductions for pension payments, health insurance, and workers' compensation.
  • Making deductions for salary garnishment or child support as authorized by court orders
  • Employee expenditure reimbursement
  • Filing and paying employment and payroll taxes on the company's behalf
  • Keeping track of employee remuneration.

Advantages of Using a PEO

  • Lower Insurance Rates: One of the benefits of working with a PEO is the possibility of lower insurance rates, especially for workers' compensation and health insurance. PEOs have the bargaining leverage to negotiate lower insurance costs since they manage a big pool of employees across different firms. This can significantly reduce costs, especially for smaller businesses with little bargaining power.

  • Legal counsel: Another advantage that some PEOs provide is legal counsel. A PEO may occasionally share legal responsibilities and liabilities with your company. This has the potential to be game-changing, particularly for companies working in areas with complex rules. However, clarifying the scope and restrictions of these legal services with the PEO is critical to ensure that they satisfy your specific requirements.

The Drawbacks of Using a PEO

  • State Unemployment Taxes: An unexpected disadvantage is that some PEOs continue to collect state unemployment taxes after the threshold has been met. This can result in excessive fees for your company and should be carefully considered while looking for a PEO.
  • Limited Healthcare Providers: Another disadvantage for businesses operating in various states is the limited network of healthcare providers that the PEO's plans may cover. This can be especially problematic for employees living where the PEO's healthcare network is more minor, perhaps leading to unhappiness.

Advantages of Using a Payroll Service

  • Streamlined Services: Payroll Providers focus exceptionally well on payroll processing. Their services are frequently simple, allowing firms to manage payroll efficiently without the added complications of PEO. This is especially advantageous for businesses that do not require the complete HR services PEOs provide.

  • Payroll Providers are generally less expensive than PEOs in terms of cost. This is especially true for organizations that only require payroll services and do not require the additional HR functions provided by PEOs. Payroll providers are an appealing alternative for budget-conscious enterprises due to their substantial cost savings.

Disadvantages of using payroll service.

  • Limited Services: Payroll Providers may be cheaper, but their offer is more circumscribed.

However, they only focus on payroll and tax compliance and can only offer some of the services a Professional Employer Organisation (PEO) provides. This may be a significant setback to firms seeking enhanced HR support.

  • Unlike PEOs, payroll providers do not carry any joint legal liability with your organization as a business. It implies you would be held solely responsible for any legal problems, such as adhering to employment legislation and rules. This also provides greater control, but at the same time, it implies being responsible for the worrying risks to some companies.

Things to Consider When Choosing a PEO.

It is important to note that many PEO vendors exist. Some of them are great, while others could be better. We insist you conduct market research if your company needs a PEO service provider. Before talking to several organizations, you should identify what products and services your company requires.

Think of the biggies but also look for local – just because a PEO is not a national firm doesn't mean it cannot provide the service you need. Husys would be a great starting point since you could identify PEOs in a particular state and have accreditation.

Conclusion

No matter how small or big a company is, PEOs are essential. Such organizations can help in cases as simple as payment and benefits administration or comply with the Work Act and visa procedures, among others.

When choosing to use a PEO, it is essential to choose the right type of firm that would cater to your own specific needs and adhere to the regulatory requirements of your state or country. A co-employment PEO may also be an alternative if your organization is small. On the other hand, large businesses could consider a PEO payroll provider. A global PEO is more economical for companies aiming to go globally than competitors.

 

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the author by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.
Ryan Taylor 2
Joined: 8 months ago
Comments (0)

    No comments yet

You must be logged in to comment.

Sign In / Sign Up