Here are a few suggestions of film journals where you may find a review of Nightmare on Elm Street:

1. Sight & Sound - The International Film Magazine
2. Film Comment - The official publication of The Film Society of Lincoln Center
3. Empire Magazine - The world's biggest movie magazine
4. American Cinematographer - The official publication of the American Society of Cinematographers

You can check the archives of these publications for a review of Nightmare on Elm Street.